NAS, SharePoint or a server: where should a small company keep files?

A comparison of NAS, SharePoint/OneDrive and a file server: cost, remote access, backup and security, plus recommendations for different types of company.

3 min

Once a company grows beyond a few people, files on someone's laptop and a USB stick are no longer enough. The main options are a network drive in the office (NAS), the Microsoft 365 cloud (SharePoint and OneDrive) or your own server. Each has strengths, and the right choice depends on how your people work.

Comparison

NASSharePoint / OneDriveServer
Cost structureOne-off purchase of the device and disks, disk replacements laterMonthly licence per user, storage includedHighest up-front cost, plus licences, power and maintenance
Remote accessVia VPN or the vendor's cloud serviceFrom anywhere in the browser and appsVia VPN
BackupMust be solved separately (second device or cloud)Built-in recycle bin and versions; separate backup for longer periodsMust be solved separately
SecurityDepends on updates and configuration; exposing it to the internet is riskyMFA, conditional access, Microsoft's infrastructureFull control, but also full responsibility
Sharing externallyLimited and awkwardEasy, with permissions and expiring linksLimited
Working offlineWorks in the officeOnly synced filesWorks in the office
Large files (video, CAD)Fast on the local networkDepends on the internet connectionFast on the local network

Typical recommendations

  • Office work, 3–30 people, already on Microsoft 365: SharePoint for shared files (one site or library per department or project) and OneDrive for personal work files. No extra hardware needed.
  • Many mobile or remote workers: the cloud is almost always better, because a NAS over VPN is slower and more cumbersome.
  • Large files (design, video, architecture, photography): a NAS in the office for fast work, with the cloud or a second NAS for backup.
  • Accounting or production software that needs a local database: a server or virtual server, as such software usually does not work properly from a synced folder.
  • A strict requirement to keep data on your own premises: a NAS or server with proper backup and remote access via VPN.

Hybrid setups

Many companies are best served by a combination. For example, everyday documents in SharePoint, large media files on the office NAS, and the NAS backing itself up to the cloud overnight. Another common pattern is a server for the accounting software and everything else in Microsoft 365. What matters is that each type of file has one clear home and staff know where to put what.

Migration tips

  1. Clean up before moving. Leave old and duplicate files behind or archive them separately.
  2. Plan the structure and permissions. Do not copy the old folder tree one to one. In SharePoint several smaller libraries work better than one huge one.
  3. Check file names and path lengths. Very long paths and some special characters cause sync problems.
  4. Move in one go and agree a cut-over day. Afterwards make the old location read-only so nobody keeps saving there.
  5. Train staff on sharing files, OneDrive sync and how to find a previous version.

When to call a professional

If your files are currently scattered across several places, or the move involves accounting or other business-critical software, it is worth going through the plan with a specialist first. ITABIKS can help choose and set up the right solution and look after server and backup maintenance, phone +372 53 888 229.

Was this article helpful?